Title Author Date

Regarding Harun Yahya Chughtai , Mobeen Jun 03, 2006

Hello There.

I'm a citizen of Pakistan; I am a communist. Now while I am not sure about your stance on the latter, i just wanted to thank you for the
excellent critique you have drafted of the assertions presented by Harun Yahya.

I am in the process of dealing with Islamo-Fascists at this time. The debate, as it stands, will soon come to a head with me defending a Scientific-Material interpretation of History while they will present the
case, as it is presented, by Harun Yahya.

Again, i just wanted to thank you and request permission to cite your article in my debate.

Best Regards,

Mobeen Chughtai.
Pakistan.

Title Author Date

Regarding Harun Yahya TalkReason , Jun 03, 2006

Dear Mr. Chugtai:

Of course you may cite the material posted on Talk Reason - you need no special permission for
that.

Regarding our attitude to your being a communist, it is your privilege to adhere to any worldview of your choice. However, we can't forget the enormous sufferings of millions of people caused by the communist rule,
whenever communists had power to put their philosophy into practice. The names of such mass murderers as Stalin, Pol Pot, Mao and their ilk speak for themselves. Islamo-fascism (and nazism) are grave dangers to humanity, but
communism, as experience has shown, is hardly much better. In fact, the real nature of islamo-fascists and of communists is very similar, despite their being enemies of each other. Both despise freedom of thought, impose by force their ideology, and strive to mercilessly annihilate those disagreeing
with them.

Talk Reason